
Cases of transnational repression can be hard to track as they take different forms often unreported and unmeasurable, especially if it’s not direct or physical. Members of the Hong Kong diaspora have experienced intimidation, threats, stalking, and assaults at universities and public protests. In 2019, Hong Kong activist Frances Hui was targeted by Chinese agents who stalked her and monitored her activities. These incidents create a chilling effect on the entire diaspora who might fear expressing any criticism of the Chinese government, resulting in self-censorship.
Between 2023 and 2024, the Hong Kong government placed HK$1 million bounties on 19 overseas Hong Kongers based in the U.S., U.K. Australia, and Canada under the city’s National Security Law, including CFHK Foundation’s Frances Hui and Chloe Cheung. The Hong Kong government also revoked the Hong Kong passports of 13 of them.
The Hong Kong Economic and Trade Offices (HKETOs), located around the world, are key players in the transnational repression of Hong Kongers overseas. The HKETOs operate in host countries with quasi-diplomatic status to promote Beijing’s narrative, influence foreign policies, and monitor dissidents. In May 2024, the London HKETO was found to be involved in assisting the Hong Kong intelligence service in information gathering, spying on pro-democracy activists, and forcing entry into a residential home.
In the U.S., a bipartisan, bicameral Transnational Repression Policy Act in Congress seeks to establish countering transnational repression as a foreign policy priority. The proposed bill mandates the administration to impose sanctions on perpetrators, develop a strategy to promote initiatives that enhance international awareness of transnational repression, address the issue, provide training to federal employees and law enforcement agencies, and conduct outreach to victims targeted by foreign governments.
Additionally, to address transnational repression against Hong Kong dissidents, governments should:
- Make full use of the Global Magnitsky Act and other sanctioning authorities to hold bad actors accountable for intimidating and threatening overseas Hong Kongers, in cooperation with multinational allies.
- Revoke HKETO’s diplomatic immunities and privileges and shut down the offices ultimately. In the U.S., Members of Congress had introduced the Hong Kong Economic and Trade Office Certification Act which would require the administration to certify whether HKETOs should merit certain privileges and immunities.
- Codify and define transnational repression in the national criminal code.
- Provide victims of transnational repression with emotional, personal, and legal support.
- Provide training to law enforcement agencies, educators, and employers on handling reports of transnational repression.
- Provide education for civil society and human rights defenders, especially those who are most vulnerable and subject to high risk of transnational repression, to better handle threats or actual violence and to take precautionary measures to protect themselves.
- Coordinate with allies on intelligence and investigation to tackle any targeted global actions against dissidents.